When analyzing categorical data in medical and biological research, researchers often want to determine whether there is an association between two variables. Two widely used statistical tests for this purpose are Fisher’s Exact Test and the Chi-Squared Test. These tests help determine whether a relationship exists between groups, but they do not indicate the strength or direction of the association. This article will explain these tests in a clear and practical way, along with methods to assess the direction of association.
Fisher’s Exact Test
Fisher’s Exact Test is used to determine if there is a non-random association between two categorical variables, particularly in small sample sizes. Unlike the chi-squared test, Fisher’s test calculates an exact probability, making it ideal when the expected frequency of any category is low.
Example of Fisher’s Exact Test in Medicine
Suppose a hospital is studying the effectiveness of a new antibiotic by comparing recovery rates between two small groups of patients: those who received the antibiotic and those who did not. If one group has fewer than five cases in a category (e.g., only three patients did not recover), Fisher’s Exact Test is the preferred method to assess whether there is an association between antibiotic use and recovery.
Key Points About Fisher’s Exact Test:
- Best for small sample sizes or when expected frequencies are low.
- Provides an exact p-value, rather than an approximation.
- Tests whether two categorical variables are associated but does not measure the strength or direction of that association.
Chi-Squared Test
The Chi-Squared Test is another widely used method to determine whether an association exists between two categorical variables. It is particularly useful for large datasets where expected frequencies are sufficient.
Example of the Chi-Squared Test in Public Health
A researcher investigates whether smoking status (smoker vs. non-smoker) is associated with lung disease (present vs. absent). The data are collected from a large group of patients, and the chi-squared test is applied to assess if there is a significant association between smoking and lung disease.
Key Points About the Chi-Squared Test:
- Suitable for larger sample sizes.
- Assumes that expected frequencies in each group are not too low (generally at least five per category).
- Determines whether an association exists but does not indicate the direction or strength of the association.
Finding the Strength and Direction of Association
Since both Fisher’s Exact Test and the Chi-Squared Test only tell us whether an association exists but not how strong or in what direction, researchers use additional methods to explore these aspects.
1. Odds Ratio (OR) and Relative Risk (RR)
These measures help quantify the strength and direction of the association between two categorical variables.
- Odds Ratio (OR): Commonly used in case-control studies. It tells us how much more likely one group is to experience an outcome compared to another.
- Relative Risk (RR): Used in cohort studies to compare the probability of an outcome occurring in exposed vs. unexposed groups.
Example: If smokers have a relative risk of 3 for lung cancer, it means they are three times more likely to develop lung cancer than non-smokers.
2. Phi Coefficient and Cramer’s
These measures assess the strength of association for categorical variables:
- Phi Coefficient (for 2×2 tables) measures the association between two binary variables.
- Cramer’s V (for larger tables) provides a value between 0 and 1, where values closer to 1 indicate a stronger association.
3. Logistic Regression
When researchers want to adjust for multiple variables, logistic regression is a powerful method. It estimates the odds of an outcome while controlling for confounding factors.
Example: A logistic regression model can examine the association between high cholesterol and heart disease while accounting for other risk factors such as age and smoking.
Importantly, at Nezu Biotech GmbH, we offer Data Analyses Services to life science institutions – both from academia and industry. The goal is clear: we take care of the data analysis, ensuring correctness and speed, so your team can focus on other important tasks.
Conclusion
Fisher’s Exact Test and the Chi-Squared Test are essential tools in medical and biological research for determining whether an association exists between categorical variables. However, they do not indicate the direction or strength of the relationship. To interpret the strength of association, researchers use measures like odds ratios, relative risk, phi coefficient, Cramer’s V, and logistic regression. Understanding when to use each method ensures that researchers draw meaningful conclusions from their data, leading to better decision-making in healthcare and biology.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this learning center is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered as medical, legal, or professional advice. While we strive to ensure accuracy, we do not guarantee that all content is up to date or free from errors. This material is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease, nor should it replace professional medical advice, consultation, or care. Users are encouraged to consult with qualified professionals before making any decisions based on the information provided. The company assumes no responsibility for any consequences resulting from the use or misuse of this content, and by accessing this information, users agree that the company is not liable for any direct or indirect damages arising from reliance on the material presented here.